As-salaam alaykum Dr Shabbir,
Can you please kindly explain what are some of the key differences that exist that separates the original Islam (Number 1 Islam or Non-Ajami Islam) from the version propogated by Ahle-Quran folks?
Thank you for your time.
Allah hafiz,
Naushad, Atlanta, USA.
Difference between Ahle-Quran and Number 1 Islam?
-
Naushad
- Posts: 101
- Joined: Tue Dec 26, 2006 10:01 pm
- Contact:
-
abshoeb
- Posts: 61
- Joined: Thu Dec 21, 2006 3:53 pm
- Contact:
Difference between Ahle-Quran and Number 1 Islam?
Salam
Basic error of the Ahl-e-Quran is that they started defining from the Quran the details of the injunctions, which the Quran has given in principles only. Its result could have been nothing except guessing and conjecturing.
For example The verses pertaining to the elements and recitals of Namaaz are also found in the Quran, through which the Ahadith can be rectified, for nobility. All the Ahadith narrated in contradiction to the Quran are all coined definitely, for example the traditions (Ahadith) pertaining to ‘leaving hands straight down in the standing position (Qayaam) during Namaaz’ or ‘tying hands down to the umbilicus’ are against the teaching of the Quran. Hazart Moses (God bless him) was ordained to put his hand in the collar. Us look ya da fee jai be ka (28: 32). Simultaneously there was another order: with one hand, catch the other. Waz mum elai ka jana ha ka min-ur-rah be (28: 32). Tie hands on your breast in such a way that you may keep on catching one hand well dressed with the other.
QXP
28:32 “The Guidance enshrined in your heart will shine unblemished when you present it with confidence. And guard your heart against all fear. Then these two shall be your evidences from your Lord to Pharaoh and his chiefs, (the Divine Truth and your confident presentation). Verily, they are people drifting away from Moral Values
Did you dilate upon, which verse of the Quran has been used for “corroborating the tying of hands on the breast during the Namaaz”? – From that verse which has nothing to do with Salaat. Since Salat is divine system and it is not ritual.
.” Deducing from this verse that God has ordained the Muslims to tie-up their hands on the breast is (God forbid) jesting with the Quran. (The Ahl-e-Quran faction usually puts this reason forth and if we are not mistaken, Maulana Abdullah Chakralvi (deceased) gushed forth this very reason).
Ali Bin Ali Alharbi (Al Madina)
Basic error of the Ahl-e-Quran is that they started defining from the Quran the details of the injunctions, which the Quran has given in principles only. Its result could have been nothing except guessing and conjecturing.
For example The verses pertaining to the elements and recitals of Namaaz are also found in the Quran, through which the Ahadith can be rectified, for nobility. All the Ahadith narrated in contradiction to the Quran are all coined definitely, for example the traditions (Ahadith) pertaining to ‘leaving hands straight down in the standing position (Qayaam) during Namaaz’ or ‘tying hands down to the umbilicus’ are against the teaching of the Quran. Hazart Moses (God bless him) was ordained to put his hand in the collar. Us look ya da fee jai be ka (28: 32). Simultaneously there was another order: with one hand, catch the other. Waz mum elai ka jana ha ka min-ur-rah be (28: 32). Tie hands on your breast in such a way that you may keep on catching one hand well dressed with the other.
QXP
28:32 “The Guidance enshrined in your heart will shine unblemished when you present it with confidence. And guard your heart against all fear. Then these two shall be your evidences from your Lord to Pharaoh and his chiefs, (the Divine Truth and your confident presentation). Verily, they are people drifting away from Moral Values
Did you dilate upon, which verse of the Quran has been used for “corroborating the tying of hands on the breast during the Namaaz”? – From that verse which has nothing to do with Salaat. Since Salat is divine system and it is not ritual.
.” Deducing from this verse that God has ordained the Muslims to tie-up their hands on the breast is (God forbid) jesting with the Quran. (The Ahl-e-Quran faction usually puts this reason forth and if we are not mistaken, Maulana Abdullah Chakralvi (deceased) gushed forth this very reason).
Ali Bin Ali Alharbi (Al Madina)