Prayer without meaning

[Sultan Abdul Hameed, Muscat]

Prayer without meaning

[Dr Shabbir, Florida]

I am delighted to see your convincing response.


Thanks, and may Allah bless you!

[Kaukab Siddique, Baltimore]

Imam Bukhari: Giant of Hadith Scholarship who Stands in way of Attempts to Misinterpret the Qur'an


Kaukab Siddique, PhD

[Badar Habib US]

[jawaid ahmed]

We can argue too and fro, so in order for us to both agree on a point, can you quote me a verse in the Qur'an that says we can follow the hadith and sunnah of the Messenger?


As for Bukhari, you have to take his word he checked the credibility of those in his chains of narrations including the four or five generation of dead ones.

Also, he did not check what was being said so gave us hadith that are absurd, contradictory to Qur'an and science, INSULTS THE Messenger and sahaba etc

It is no good telling us that a person is honest when his testimony is dishonest!


If you have studied hadith then you should know about these problems in Bukhari unless you are one of those that believes in him 100%, an absolute hadithist.

[abdalaziz ariff / indiana]

The Creator has left nothing out, whatever is needed is there and any thing else is just opinion.


Once Qur'an understood, the traditional namaz disappears.

[abdalaziz ariff / indiana]

[Saira Iqbal, uk]

Please give your strong and elaborate reasonings (including Quran verses) as to why you believe every Hadith in the sahih is correct without mentioning the following:

• because it’s by buhkari

• that’s what ‘true’ Muslims believe in

• gives us guidance on how to understand and follow the teachings of the Qur'an

• teach Muslims how to live their lives


Quran is enough for the last three points by the way.

[Muhammad Rafi Karachi]